Recent comments in /f/dataisbeautiful
monissa t1_jdw6d7o wrote
Reply to Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
I didn't expect galicia to be such a public transport powerhouse
DamonFields t1_jdw5w11 wrote
Reply to [OC] What went wrong at Credit Suisse by giteam
Personally , I’d avoid any bank catering to money laundering and crony investing.
LC1903 t1_jdw5j11 wrote
Reply to comment by TravelTime_LKB in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
These are all kinda population density maps, because all of these countries have solid public transport
harkening t1_jdw4z9z wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
Belgium is less than a quarter the land area of England.
This shows density, but with no regard for scale. Also no accounting for where people live - i.e. population distribution and density.
r/dataismisleading
TravelTime_LKB OP t1_jdw4q8e wrote
Reply to comment by pingieking in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
It's quite similar to population density maps for Spain - you can see similar patterns here too https://twitter.com/simongerman600/status/1610307502553370627?t=1gcobn_UITwz6SNCZUtHAQ&s=19
Help_Glum t1_jdw4c6g wrote
Reply to [OC] Percentage of People in Poverty by State Using 3-Year Average: 2019, 2020, and 2021 (Supplemental Poverty Measure) by FlyingSquirlez
I’ve never heard of the SPM, very interesting. Thanks, OP.
pingieking t1_jdw42w4 wrote
Reply to Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
Why does Spain only have that one corner done? It can't be that people only live there, can it?
TravelTime_LKB OP t1_jdw40r1 wrote
Reply to comment by historycat95 in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
We should try this next! We have an internal tool that maps our public transport providers in the US so thought I'd share the screenshot.
Spoiler: it's quite sparse!
JackdiQuadri97 t1_jdw3jzq wrote
Reply to Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
You clearly have very poor data sources for Italy
TravelTime_LKB OP t1_jdw3cqv wrote
Reply to comment by lotosprendidos in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
Agreed! Population would help us understand transport demand, whilst geography will impact where stations can be located.
TravelTime_LKB OP t1_jdw35b9 wrote
Reply to comment by icelandichorsey in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
Just want to check I'm answering correctly, what do you mean as underserved? As the maps were created by pinpointing where public transport stops are, and a surrounding 15 min walking area, locations where there's large bodies of water would not be coloured purple as there's no station.
lizufyr t1_jdw29o4 wrote
Reply to comment by lotosprendidos in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
True, but then Switzerland would look very different. It’s less about cost and more about need.
historycat95 t1_jdw269i wrote
Reply to Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
And the US?
File not found.
FlyingSquirlez OP t1_jdw1e68 wrote
Reply to comment by GeneralMe21 in [OC] Percentage of People in Poverty by State Using 3-Year Average: 2019, 2020, and 2021 (Supplemental Poverty Measure) by FlyingSquirlez
Mississippi has the highest official poverty rate, but when adjusted for cost of living it drops "all the way down" to fourth highest (including DC).
ottoottootto t1_jdw16e2 wrote
Reply to comment by TriFolk in [OC] 2022 Income & expenses Sankey for family of 3.5 in SoCal by budgetthrowaway1209
I downvoted because I am tired of seeing personal finance Sankey thingies. I don't find them interesting. Your assumption is wrong.
TravelTime_LKB OP t1_jdw0ofj wrote
Reply to comment by 11160704 in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
Thanks. I'll have our data team look into it but most likely if they're spaced out, once we zoomed it out and exported at a country level it wasn't too visible.
lotosprendidos t1_jdw0dpm wrote
Reply to comment by lizufyr in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
And orography. Spain is hilly af. It affects the cost of railroads.
icelandichorsey t1_jdw04ah wrote
Reply to Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
Hmm and now are large bodies of water handled? Doesn't seem like they're handled very well, eg Sweden and Switzerland are full of lakes that on your map look like undeserved areas
11160704 t1_jdvz04b wrote
Reply to comment by TravelTime_LKB in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
But for example the Sorrento peninsula is almost empty, despite the fact that it has a dense public transport network.
TravelTime_LKB OP t1_jdvyq33 wrote
Reply to comment by 11160704 in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
The database does include Campania transport networks. The reason it looks so different is because of transport density - whilst there are transport routes in this area, it's not dense. In the visualisation each stop only has a 15 minute walking catchment area around it, so if the stops are few and far between, at the zoom level it won't show a lot of coverage. You can see when you open up the map in more detail here that there are routes in the area.
GeneralMe21 t1_jdvyh95 wrote
Reply to [OC] Percentage of People in Poverty by State Using 3-Year Average: 2019, 2020, and 2021 (Supplemental Poverty Measure) by FlyingSquirlez
Mississippi not winning this battle?
goldenhairmoose t1_jdvy5x5 wrote
Reply to [OC] My partner’s 2 months job hunt as a Product Manager (UK, 4 years xp) by fryd_rice_all_rise
And after 8 interviews they're going to offer 50k£ in London area...
FlyingSquirlez OP t1_jdvxyqi wrote
Reply to [OC] Percentage of People in Poverty by State Using 3-Year Average: 2019, 2020, and 2021 (Supplemental Poverty Measure) by FlyingSquirlez
The SPM, first released in 2011 and produced with support from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), extends the official poverty measure by taking account of many government programs that are designed to assist low-income families but are not included in the official poverty measure. The SPM also includes federal and state taxes and work and medical expenses. In addition, the SPM accounts for geographic variation in poverty thresholds, while the official poverty measure does not.
Census website that has the report data, including useful statistics such as official poverty measure by state, margins of error, and further information on how poverty data is collected in the census: https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-277.html
The map was created using MapChart.
lizufyr t1_jdvxj0d wrote
Reply to Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
It would be interesting to correlate this with population density. Like, Spain looks pretty empty until you realise that the population is actually focused mostly around few big cities, while Germany had lots of villages and small towns throughout its area.
TravelTime_LKB OP t1_jdw79zp wrote
Reply to comment by harkening in Compare Public Transport Network Connectivity In 10 European Countries [OC] by TravelTime_LKB
I'll hold my hands up and say for the sake of the infographic we had to use different zoom levels, I'll make sure to do it better next time!
Just did a quick screenshot using the same zoom level on our internal tool if you'd like to compare Great Britain with Belgium if anyone's interested. As a whole, I'd still say Belgium's connectivity is better, but obviously it's a smaller country so will be easier to get full coverage.